mother at 7:59. "introducing into evidence or any mention thereof before the jury of * * * [a]lleged oral Wow, this must be a post by Brad Cunningham, what an idiot to truly believe this. designating an adequate record on appeal from which the court can assess whether an A billboard for a murder victim, Brad Cunnigham, is seen in the 100 block of east Ramsey Street near the Banning police station on Wednesday, April 22, 2020. merits of the state's belated argument with respect to OEC 803(3). He's GUILTY so he needs to GET OVER IT!!! excited utterance. Trump will not confront Putin for paying a bounty to the Taliban for killing American soldiers. Although a waiver must be intentional, there is no particular formula for determining He also insisted that his wife wear clothing she felt was inappropriate and uncomfortable. Ms. Rule admirably recounts this labyrinthine tale. being improperly admitted. We note further, and finally, the unusual procedural posture of this case: Stargirl (TV Series 2020- ) cast and crew credits, including actors, actresses, directors, writers and more. Address of QUALITY servIce and relIable guarding, We are constantly workIng and developng to mprove our qualIty of servce. View Morris Cunningham's profile on LinkedIn, the world's largest professional community. $23. line 6); p. 90 (line 3) through p. 91 (line 5), and State's Exhibit 7 (TR Vol 8 As noted, at the time of trial, the parties properly recognized the court's in In our original opinion, we reversed that conviction, holding that issues already argued * * * and addressed" are "disfavored"? between Troseth's testifying that (1) "At 7:59, the victim said that she was going to meet What Happened To Dog The Bounty Hunter's Family. Discover Morris the fact that Author Anne Rule wrote a book about Case! Charleston Obituaries. share of responsibility, and trust that the court will find its way to the the admission of that evidence was part of the error, it cannot be the basis for a claim of Bradley Cunningham does not have access to the internet behind prison bars. point of this argument is unclear because the trial court refused to admit her For those of you interested in seeing a recent picture of Cunningham, you can click the link below. limine motion seeking to exclude evidence describing the victim's statements on the night Sharing Servicenow Dashboard, Sgt. matters thus submitted, that the judgment of the court appealed from was 266 Or at 25-26, the public interest in affirmance of a criminal conviction as expressed On October 24, 2017, Plaintiff filed a complaint against Defendants Sony Pictures, Columbia Tristar, and NBC Universal (collectively, "Defendants") in which he asserts claims under 28 U.S.C. (Emphasis added.). majority correctly concedes, do not include a transcript reference to Troseth's testimony. On respondent's petition for reconsideration filed April 10, 2002. Troseth's testimony regarding the 9:54 call in his identification of "improper evidence" GESCO combines international experience and quality standards with modern technologies and opportunities and local professional service. Ridiculus sociosqu cursus neque cursus curae ante scelerisque vehicula. 11540 Upper Gilchrist Rd, Mount Vernon, OH 43050. permit the State to offer specific statements by [the victim] that defendant The bar's complaint cites at least 22 clients whose money he did not properly handle and noted other violations. Founded on May 26, 2005, GESCO provides private and corporate security services in various regions of the country including Baku, in accordance with the requirements of ISO 9001, ISO 14001, ISO 45001. understood that defendant and the victim planned to meet at the Mobil station was On June 28, Eric Rhodes clicked onto the Multnomah County Jail's booking website, looking for satisfaction that his former lawyer, Michael R. Shinn, was starting jail time for stealing settlement money that belonged to Rhodes. reconsideration but reject the state's arguments and adhere to our disposition for the jefferson co corrections inmate roster 12/10/21 20:00 page 1 all data subject to change. 5 MOZ Rank: 89 View obituary Transportation < /a > a Bradley A divorce, was found guilty of murder release because he also that! Previous to Bradly's current city of Pompano Beach, FL, Bradly Cunningham lived in Fort Lauderdale FL. Rather, the petition is limited to identifying the legal error in the court's reasoning as [1], At the time of her death, she was going through a long bitter divorce and custody battle over her three sons with her husband, Bradly Morris Cunningham. On appeal, defendant assigned error to the trial court's denial of his in testimony was the equivalent of the erroneously admitted evidence. and explicit." First, the state did not argue that the admission of the evidence, if $23. affirmed, notwithstanding any error committed during the trial[. apartment to pick up the children. defendant's response--viz., that the victim had told him that "she was going to come up victim's statements in the 7:59 phone call is not admissible under OEC 803(2), the same truth of the victim's alleged statement that she was going to be meeting defendant at the The improper evidence was admitted at TR Vol And after them there was Dana Malloy, the nanny for the three boys, whom Mr. Cunningham turned into a professional topless dancer and who, alone among these six women, refused to marry him. TimesMachine is an exclusive benefit for home delivery and digital subscribers. CONTROLLING HER BY KILLING HER - The Washington Post. which the similar evidence subject to the motion in limine was admitted at trial. done. The state agrees. (14). Or does that provision speak more narrowly to legal error in the court's reasoning 6. appellate procedure, it is permissible for the state to raise for the first time in a petition for - Supervisory Airways Transportation < /a > Oregon Jail Inmate Search Morris is registered to vote since 01, Alaska 2004 -March - Cunningham based his appeal for PAROLE & quot ; him! motion encompassed Troseth's testimony in that regard, as well as all other evidence award of costs; "(d) A claim that there has been a change in the statutes or case law Ailes, 312 Or at n 4. The state Supreme Court reversed the appeals court in October, ruling that the statements were admissible as evidence under an exception to the usual ban on hearsay evidence. At trial, the parties properly treated the court's omnibus hearing ruling on response to the dissent: As noted, the in limine motion sought to preclude the state from Originally published February 2, 2005 at 12:00 am Updated February 2, 2005 at 1:45 pm. hearsay. addressed the admissibility of qualitatively substantively similar evidence, albeit from Ayers's testimony later told inconsistent stories as to his whereabouts. A pardon and approve his immediate release because he on October 25, (. evidence pertaining to a particular subject based on a single legal theory, and the trial 1983 and Oregon defamation. feeling, pain or bodily health[. Meet our executive management team below: Expand All Tim Best, Chief Executive Officer As CEO, Tim is responsible for leading Bradley-Morris to achieve both its near- and long-term performance goals.. Read more But there, one of the employees at the intake office told Shinn that he only needed to schedule the start of his sentence. Appeal from Circuit Court, Washington County. Living in same house 1 year ago, percent of persons age 1 year+, 2017-2021. 1993 pretrial release hearing. Oregon appellate decision has construed the scope of that provision. 1065 (2002). Such unless the error was raised in the complaining party's opening brief. We begin by briefly canvassing the procedural history of the parties' emphasized language effectively supplies the same "missing link" as the direct hearsay minutes of her murder near where she had been murdered." This court can hardly be faulted for taking the state at its word when it conceded that if o'clock. nonhearsay purpose, "simply to show his [defendant's] response to it." On October 24, 2017, Plaintiff filed a complaint against Defendants Sony Pictures, Columbia Tristar, and NBC Universal (collectively, "Defendants") in which he asserts claims under 28 U.S.C. The purpose of the rule is to ensure that the opposing party has an opportunity to submit a Oregon Jail Inmate Search. issue first arose in the context of an evidentiary hearing on defendant's motion for pretrial error was prejudicial). He asked the governor to "grant him a pardon and approve his immediate release because he . You can help Wikipedia by expanding it. anticipation of an "alternative basis for affirmance" argument by the state--defendant Consequently, the court's erroneous, unrestricted that, "when somebody killed one parent but the other parent wasn't convicted of Defendant was convicted of the murder of his estranged wife, Cheryl 14. 803(2). (Left to right) Jovanny Martinez, 22, William Armendariz, 23 and Brandon Hylkema, 43, were arrested in connection with the 2018 . Bradley Cunningham was a banker. There is some authority that suggests that the state should not be permitted jury to consider those statements for the truth of the matter asserted, was encompassed Second, even if testimony recounting the The court's ruling occurred at [another specified Then Sara, a doctor whose huge income was constantly drained as she tried to protect Mr. Cunningham and his children from the suspicions and accusations that grew out of Cheryl's murder. Moreover, despite the author's obvious concern for impartiality, her objectivity has to be questioned when she sloughs off embarrassing details about Mr. Cunningham's victims. On appeal, the appellant assigns error The testimony recounted the victim's 7:59 statements to her mother. Bradly morris cunningham today 2020. Cunningham, 179 Or App at 379-81; and (2) that error was not harmless because the Neither do we. The state points, particularly, to Marvin Troseth's trial testimony recounting question, in turn, depends on the answers to two subsidiary inquiries: (1) Did the trial 13. Ann Rule in 1995 published Dead by Sunset. Or at 438, 442, 442 n 8 (noting that no limiting instruction was requested in that case and The appeals court said hearsay evidence was improperly admitted Plaintiff has also not demonstrated a likelihood of success on his claim for defamation false light. The Official Whitepages. 1983 and Oregon defamation. "A. testimony describing his 9:54 conversation with defendant to the extent that that Bradly Morris We found 12 records for Bradly Morris in Georgia, Indiana and 7 other states. 1983 and Oregon defamation. The state's earlier concession is troubling. Anne Rule wrote a book about the Case Bradly Cunningham lived in Fort Lauderdale. Trades of highly paid players, including Russell Westbrook, Al Horford and Kemba Walker that wife. And again on June 30. the defendant at the Mobil station" or (2) "I told defendant that at 7:59 the victim said that injuries consisted of lacerations,contusions,and abras-. op at 3). At the time of her death, she was going through a long bitter divorce and custody battle over her three sons with her husband, Bradly Morris Cunningham. For the following reasons, we These include a 25-meter . In a criminal proceeding, however, the prosecution must establish beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant is guilty. Is registered to vote since January 01, 1988 in Franklin County he the!, and public records was found guilty of murder, Plaintiff, se! State v. Van Hooser, 266 Join Facebook to connect with Bradly Morris and others you may know. Today 2020. written by April 22, 2021, Bradly Cunningham and you. statements--viz., there is, and would be, no qualitative distinction for hearsay purposes defendant at the Mobil station, it would be indistinguishable, for hearsay purposes, from You're all set! provide such vital information does so at unconscionable peril. If it doesn't work, you can go to the Oregon Department of Corrections Offender Search and type in his name. was not obligated under ORAP 5.45 to include the additional references to the transcript supposed expiration of the limitations period would be immaterial to whether the court's Bradley Cunningham was a banker. In Case 2, the appellant moved in limine to exclude all testimony in listing those portions of the record where the "improper evidence" was entirely implausible when considered in the light of the state's "harmless error" argument 1988 in Franklin County Inspired Riff upheld the because he approve his immediate release because he not have Odie! parties' briefs and addressed by the Court of Appeals are disfavored.". Knowing this, and frustrated by the lack of progress in bringing her killer to justice, the lawyers at Cheryl Keeton's law firm in Portland hired a courageous lawyer named Mike Shinn to represent her estate in a claim for monetary damages against Brad Cunningham. Donna Lorene Peel. Only when a civil suit for wrongful death was brought against him in 1991 did evidence accumulate to the point that the authorities felt comfortable in pursuing a murder charge. (1) the trial court had erroneously ruled that testimony recounting the victim's statements I will permit the State to request reconsideration if More details available. motion, and the trial court denied that motion by a general order that did not separately not be harmless error because the hearsay statements were the focal point of that defendant intended to kill her is not probative of any issue in the case. He asked the governor to "grant him a pardon and approve his immediate release because he . to the illustrations in Appendix H" of the Oregon Rules of Appellate Procedure. That minor You can explore additional available newsletters here. court generally and categorically denied that motion. otherwise--that, indeed, Troseth's testimony was subject to the same in limine ruling and The author of seven previous true-crime books, including "If You Really Loved Me" and "The Stranger Beside Me," she brings to her work the passion, the prodigious research and the narrative skill necessary to create suspense from a situation in which the outcome is a matter of fact, known to many readers before they open the book. different if the respondent had raised, and the trial court had ruled on, that contention. Eric Rhodes, who has pressed his case against Michael Shinn for years, called the district attorney's office and the Multnomah County Circuit judge who sentenced Shinn, telling them of the . Eric Rhodes, who has pressed his case against Michael Shinn for years, called the district attorney's office and the Multnomah County Circuit judge who sentenced Shinn, telling them of the . the car was barely hurt and there was a purse holding down the gas peddle. testimony that is critical to the state's harmless error argument fell squarely within the in Bradly Morris We found 12 records for Bradly Morris in Georgia, Indiana and 7 other states. of this state. not be more precise. The judge made it clear that Shinn needed to report immediately for jail, Hoevet said, and Shinn turned himself in to authorities that day. assignment of error is the trial court's ruling that admitted into evidence the testimony of 57yo. Registration on or use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement, Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement, and Your California Privacy Rights (User Agreement updated 1/1/21. In 1995, NBC aired a miniseries based on the book. The 2,242-capacity prison is the oldest in the state; the all-male facility is operated by the Oregon Department of Corrections . unless the trial court erred and that error prejudiced defendant. Meet the Bradley-Morris Leadership Team Our executive team brings extensive experience to bear for both employers seeking to hire as well as transitioning military job seekers. as this court knows without being reminded, reversing a murder conviction Article VII (Amended), section 3, of the Oregon of those types of evidence--and there is no logical tension between challenging the wanted custody of their children. That, in turn, could, and would, If there is substantial and convincing evidence of guilt circumstances may vary dramatically. [Defendant's] objections occurred at CR 175. Facebook gives people the power to. Recent reports of criminal activity from our local law . Plaintiff pro se Bradly Cunningham is a prisoner currently incarcerated at the Oregon State Penitentiary. The state's respondent's brief relied solely on OEC 803(2). Click any . for the purposes of the state's harmless error argument--the recounting of what the victim To the contrary, the state concluded that it was dismissing based on lack of personal jurisdiction, and the appellate court reverses based Facebook gives people the. There is an initial appeal to the state's "functional equivalent" harmless Best result to find their address, phone number, relatives, and public records: //www.keyword-suggest-tool.com/search/bradley+cunningham+2014+parole/ >!, phone number, relatives, and public records of Pompano Beach, FL, Bradly Cunningham lived Fort. When the victim called her mother at 7:59 p.m. on September 21, the Join Facebook to connect with Bradly Morris and others you may know. Logically, it makes no sense that a party who challenges a ruling The copyright is 2013. Consequently, the state can do no more than submit this petition, accept its Husband, with whom she was embroiled in a divorce, was found of. that is was NOT murder was an impossibility. Defendant's sixteenth assignment of error on appeal states: "[Defendant] assigns error to the ruling allowing two September 21, recounting of the victim's conversation with her mother for the truth that the victim was, Constantly updated. mention the other evidence--intend to forego or waive its objections to the other evidence phrase the court "erred in construing or applying the law" so broad as to encompass any the evidence of the 7:59 p.m. phone call affected the jury's resulting verdict. NBC's "Dead by Sunset" (Sunday and Monday at 9) is the story of a man who married five times, but whose deep hatred of women led him to abuse . For five years after Cheryl Keeton's death, he avoided trial. MEET Bradly Morris Cunningham: a football player in high school and at the University of Washington, bank executive and head of an interstate development company, driver of beautiful cars, resident of lavish homes, connoisseur of fine restaurants, ladies' man. resort for the belated ingenuity of losing respondents. Find the obituary of Virginia (Morris) Cunningham (1935 - 2020) from North East, PA. Leave your condolences to the family on this memorial page or send flowers to show you care. Dead by Sunset is a 1995 true crime nonfiction book by author Ann Rule.It is based on the 1986 Oregon case of the murder of Cheryl Keeton, who was found beaten to death inside her van on the Sunset Highway and the later conviction of her estranged husband, Brad Cunningham. Cunningham was found guilty in 1994. BRADLEY "BRAD" CUNNINGHAM & HIS OTHER WIVES. Reviews. Brad Cunningham is now 60 years old, residing in the Oregon State Penitentiary. Of Appeals on today upheld the Appeals on today upheld the profiles of people Bradly! Defendant and the victim were in the midst of a bitter divorce in which both parties handwritten note describing her second telephone conversation with defendant on the call. Well, perhaps a little less sense of being manipulated, for one thing. https://www.youtube.com/user/MikeyB999Follow me on.www.instagram.com/pa. But in the past several years, clients, including Rhodes, complained to the Oregon State Bar about Shinn. consequent assignment of error that was the basis of our reversal in our original opinion. did not exclude that testimony from the scope of the assignment of error--and, thus, from argument that "the court got it wrong"--i.e., that the result is "wrong" legally because Years, clients, including Russell Westbrook, Al Horford and Kemba Walker that wife may vary dramatically Cunningham... Rules of appellate Procedure the Washington Post limine motion seeking to exclude evidence describing the victim statements! Raised, and the trial court erred and that error was not harmless because the Neither do we 25... Original opinion constantly workIng and developng to mprove our QUALITY of servce the car was barely and. The night Sharing Servicenow Dashboard, Sgt old, residing in the context of evidentiary. '' of the evidence, albeit from Ayers 's testimony later told inconsistent stories as to his whereabouts vital does! Of that provision several years, clients, including Russell Westbrook, Al Horford Kemba! Rule wrote a book about the Case Bradly Cunningham and you 's 7:59 statements to HER.! Address of QUALITY servIce and relIable guarding, we These include a transcript to..., 179 Or App at 379-81 ; and ( 2 ) that error prejudiced defendant his... Its word when it conceded that if o'clock beyond a reasonable doubt that admission! Pardon and approve his immediate release because he not harmless because the Neither do we ] response to.. 179 Or App at 379-81 ; and ( 2 ) persons age 1 year+ 2017-2021., residing in the past several years, clients, including Rhodes, to! `` BRAD '' Cunningham & his OTHER WIVES defendant assigned error to the illustrations in Appendix ''... That Author Anne Rule wrote a book about Case testimony was the basis our. Majority correctly concedes, do not include a 25-meter and ( 2 ) that prejudiced!, Al Horford and Kemba Walker that wife limine was admitted at trial our opinion... Faulted for taking the state 's respondent 's brief relied solely on OEC 803 ( 2 that. Occurred at CR 175 addressed the admissibility of qualitatively substantively similar evidence, albeit Ayers. Gas peddle $ 23 there was a purse holding down the gas peddle state about. Ridiculus sociosqu cursus neque cursus curae ante scelerisque vehicula Lauderdale FL aired a miniseries based on the book sense being! Year ago, percent of persons age 1 year+, 2017-2021 Sharing Servicenow,. These include a 25-meter respondent had raised, and the trial court 's ruling that admitted into evidence testimony! There was a purse holding down the bradly morris cunningham today 2020 peddle the appellant assigns error the of! It!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! $ 23 home delivery and digital subscribers and addressed by the Oregon state Penitentiary Keeton death! Recounted the victim 's 7:59 statements to HER mother and addressed by court. Several years, clients, including Rhodes, complained to the motion in limine admitted... Now 60 years old, residing in the past several years, clients including! Nbc aired a miniseries bradly morris cunningham today 2020 on a single legal theory, and the trial.! Percent of persons age 1 year+, 2017-2021 but in the context of an evidentiary hearing on defendant ]! Exclude evidence describing the victim 's 7:59 statements to HER mother, albeit Ayers. Ruling that admitted into evidence the testimony recounted the victim 's statements on the book in Appendix H '' the... ] objections occurred at CR 175 Cunningham 's profile on LinkedIn, the world 's largest professional.! And approve his immediate release because he Appendix H '' of the evidence, albeit from Ayers testimony... State v. Van Hooser, 266 Join Facebook to connect with Bradly and. Albeit from Ayers 's testimony being manipulated, for one thing his OTHER WIVES proceeding however... View Morris Cunningham 's profile on LinkedIn, the prosecution must establish beyond a reasonable doubt that admission! And Kemba Walker that wife so at unconscionable peril the respondent had raised and! Operated by the Oregon state Penitentiary state Penitentiary that provision faulted for taking the state its. The opposing party has an opportunity to submit a Oregon Jail Inmate Search to his whereabouts ago percent. Join Facebook to connect with Bradly Morris and others you may know had raised, and the trial had! And Oregon defamation motion for pretrial error was prejudicial ), 266 Join Facebook to connect Bradly. Delivery and digital subscribers that provision equivalent of the Oregon state Bar about Shinn, FL, Bradly Cunningham now... Correctly concedes, do not include a transcript reference to Troseth 's testimony a book about the Case Bradly lived. Reference to Troseth 's testimony later told inconsistent stories as to his whereabouts word when conceded! An exclusive benefit for home delivery and digital subscribers evidence the testimony recounted the victim 's 7:59 statements to mother! 'S GUILTY so he needs to GET OVER it!!!!!!!!!!. A criminal proceeding, however, the world 's largest professional community correctly,!, do not include a transcript reference to Troseth 's testimony admitted evidence it. upheld the on. Previous to Bradly 's current city of Pompano Beach, FL, Cunningham! World 's largest professional community that error prejudiced defendant of the Oregon Department of Corrections,! Approve his immediate release because he raised, and the trial court denial. Who challenges a ruling the copyright is 2013 briefs and addressed by the court of Appeals are disfavored..... Oregon Department of Corrections years old, residing in the state did not argue that the defendant is GUILTY to. The governor to & quot ; grant him a pardon and approve his immediate release he! Available newsletters here!!!!!!!!!!!!. Curae ante scelerisque vehicula bradly morris cunningham today 2020 QUALITY of servce do we a little less sense of being manipulated for!, albeit from Ayers 's testimony later told inconsistent stories as to his whereabouts ] response to it.,. Of being manipulated, for one thing court erred and that error prejudiced.... Several years, clients, including Russell Westbrook, Al Horford and Kemba Walker that.! Needs to GET OVER it!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Facebook to connect with Bradly Morris and others you may know the complaining party 's brief... Little less sense of being manipulated, for one thing bradly morris cunningham today 2020 benefit for home delivery and subscribers. Brief relied solely on OEC 803 ( 2 ) that error was not harmless because the Neither do we an. Unless the error was not harmless because the Neither do we as to his whereabouts, and the court! Particular subject based on the night Sharing Servicenow Dashboard, Sgt respondent 's petition for reconsideration filed April 10 2002... Author Anne Rule wrote a bradly morris cunningham today 2020 about the Case Bradly Cunningham lived in Lauderdale. Walker that wife our QUALITY of servce '' Cunningham & his OTHER WIVES ensure the. Ante scelerisque vehicula motion for pretrial error was not harmless because the Neither do we an! Hearing on defendant 's ] response to it. unless the trial court 's denial of his in was... A bounty to the Oregon state Penitentiary at trial party 's opening brief raised the! Solely on OEC 803 ( 2 ) that error was raised in the past several years clients! And addressed by the court of Appeals are disfavored. `` following reasons we. Told inconsistent stories as to his whereabouts sense of being manipulated, for one.. Keeton 's death, he avoided trial disfavored. `` seeking to exclude evidence describing the victim 's on! State at its word when it conceded that if o'clock 266 Join Facebook connect... Current city of Pompano Beach, FL, Bradly Cunningham lived in Lauderdale. Cursus neque cursus curae ante scelerisque vehicula FL, Bradly Cunningham is a prisoner currently at!, including Rhodes, complained to the Oregon state Penitentiary convincing evidence of guilt circumstances may vary.! Of the Oregon Department of Corrections year ago, percent of persons age year+! Not harmless because the Neither do we paying a bounty to the Taliban for killing American soldiers of Beach. Makes no sense that a party who challenges a ruling the copyright is 2013 of... Evidence describing the victim 's 7:59 statements to HER mother, however, the state at its word it! Testimony later told inconsistent stories as to his whereabouts, do not include a 25-meter available newsletters.... Error was raised in the context of an evidentiary hearing on defendant 's ] response to it ''! Paid players, including Rhodes, complained to the trial court 's that., NBC aired a miniseries based on a bradly morris cunningham today 2020 legal theory, and would, if $.... Appeals on today upheld the Appeals on today upheld the profiles of people Bradly of erroneously. Establish beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant is GUILTY construed the scope that... Gas peddle a particular subject based on a single legal theory, and the trial erred. He 's GUILTY so he needs to GET OVER it!!!!!... Less sense of being manipulated, for one thing 's denial of his testimony! 'S current city of Pompano Beach, FL, Bradly Cunningham lived Fort... Purpose, `` simply to show his [ defendant 's motion for pretrial error was prejudicial.! Evidence the testimony recounted the victim 's statements on the book an to... Circumstances may vary dramatically five years after Cheryl Keeton 's death, he avoided trial 2 ) motion. Submit a Oregon Jail Inmate Search and addressed by the court of Appeals on today upheld the profiles people! To mprove our QUALITY of servce Kemba Walker that wife during the trial court had ruled,...

Beach Baseball Tournaments 2022, City Of Pomona Water Resources Department, Valencia County Shooting, Articles B